UB Consulting: Are Consumers Facing Credit Issues?

Tuesday, 06 June 2023

According to the Q1 NY Federal Reserve Bank’s Household Debt and Credit Report, total household debt increased by nearly 1 percent from Q4 2022 to $17.05 trillion, an all-time high. On a quarter-to-quarter basis, credit card loans remained flat, totaling $986 billion. These figures raised concerns for many analysts, mainly as outstanding consumer credit card loans typically shrink during these times as consumers try to pay off holiday shopping expenditures paid by credit cards. Despite robust retail sales data, recent credit reports have sparked debates over the economic well-being of the consumer. Is the negative connotation valid? This quick piece will provide some context.

Generally, there is a common misconception about credit card balances. First, we must view credit card balances as a form of payment rather than a debt measurement. Therefore, if we assume that consumers keep their spending habits constant, higher interest rates on credit cards will cause overall debt to increase. However, consumers usually pay their credit card balances—in this context, “debt”—before the payment deadline, prior to any interest accrual. On the other hand, balances not paid off after 30 days or more are categorized as “delinquencies.”

As mentioned in a previous post, current delinquency rates sit below pre-pandemic levels, approximately 18 basis points below Q4 2019 rates (blue line chart below). Despite the historically low delinquency rates, many market analysts have been on edge given the record-high year-over-year increase rate (orange line chart below). Nevertheless, we need to analyze these figures from the proper perspective; these record-high increases came from record-low rates in 2021, which can cause the data to skew. In the previous recession, year-over-year changes increased rapidly, with overall delinquency rates surpassing 6 percent; currently, these rates sit at about 2 percent. The rapid increase is a cause for close vigilance, but not necessarily alarm.

Furthermore, one must compare these levels relative to another indicator to provide proper context to higher debt levels. Typically, debt levels are analyzed as a percentage of income. In other words, if debt rises, but income levels remain constant, debt would be a cause for concern. Currently, debt service payments as a percent of disposable income remain historically low. In Q4 2022, the ratio sat approximately 18 basis points below the pre-pandemic baseline average percentage—from 2014 to 2019. This ratio suggests that payments on debts are a relatively smaller proportion of incomes compared to previous years.

What does this mean for protein commodity market participants?

The numbers above suggest that consumers remain relatively well-positioned with their finances. As for now, the economy still faces a robust labor market with rising real wages. In our previous whitepaper, we mentioned that most indicators had not shown formal trade-down within their protein consumption.

For example, beef prices relative to lower-priced proteins, like chicken, remain elevated—partly due to tighter cattle supplies—suggesting that consumers have not traded down in their protein consumption choices. However, we must consider that chicken prices have corrected downward from all-time highs due to increased supply. Therefore, fundamentals generally explain some of the price behavior if we hold all else equal. However, “everything else” is seldom equal, so an argument could be made indicating that the trade-down remains inconclusive. If anything, and from a purely empirical perspective, consumption habits may be normalizing from the excesses caused by the pandemic.

Again, the recent data regarding consumer credit should be taken in stride. Yes, we should be aware that credit markets are tightening, and the market has witnessed increased borrowing costs. However, our take is that we should remain cautious in case delinquency rates continue to increase, incomes fall, or unemployment increases. The picture is not rosy as the economy and credit markets go through a substantial adjustment. At the moment, data suggests caution rather than panic.

Photo Credit: ViDI Studio / Shutterstock.com

Andrei Rjedkin
Urner Barry
1-732-240-5330 ext 293
arjedkin@urnerbarry.com 

Angel Rubio
Urner Barry
1-732-240-5330
arubio@urnerbarry.com